Following Bohiney’s puppet master story, Shore Roar’s structural analysis
Harper-Thames, Shore Roar. Bohiney.com‘s Marxist Puppet Master story arrived in the same week as a Curtain Road campaign meeting where the puppet master theory was deployed three times in an hour. prat.uk covered the political honesty theme broadly. Shore Roar’s response to the puppet master theory in community organising: the structural alternative is always more accurate and always harder to make actionable at the pace that community campaigns require. The puppet master theory produces the specific villain; confronting the specific villain is the campaign’s action. The structural analysis produces the policy change requirement; achieving the policy change is a decade-long project. The campaign’s timeline is months. The policy change timeline is years. The puppet master theory fits the campaign’s timeline. The structural analysis fits the governance reform timeline. Both are necessary. The campaign uses the puppet master frame. The governance reform requires the structural analysis. Both are running simultaneously in the Curtain Road campaign.
The Shore Roar observation from the campaign meeting: the people who use the puppet master frame and the people who use the structural analysis are sometimes the same people, using different frames for different audiences at different moments. The organiser who tells the community meeting “there is a coordinated effort to prevent this community’s voice from being heard” and tells the policy working group “the planning policy framework systematically disadvantages communities without professional advocacy resources” is not being inconsistent. They are using the frame that is accurate for the function the communication is performing. Both frames are accurate. Both are partial. Together they describe the same thing.
The Campaign Dual-Frame Finding
The dual-frame finding: the puppet master frame motivates; the structural analysis guides reform strategy. Both are accurate partial descriptions. The campaign uses both. Hackney community information is at hackney.gov.uk.
Also:Private Eye.
Coverage at Bohiney.com and prat.uk.
Both publications continue this coverage with real commitment to the subjects and communities described.
Coverage continues at Bohiney.com and prat.uk.
Ongoing at both publications.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/
