Hackney Council Chamber, Meet the County Commissioner

Planning disputes, cycle lanes and three Texas-style loans: local government is the same everywhere, only the hats differ

The Meeting Will Come to Order, Eventually

Local government is the great leveller. Whether you are in a council chamber in Hackney or a county courthouse in the Texas panhandle, the proceedings follow the same five stages. The agenda is read. Someone raises a point of order. A man with a laminated folder objects to a fence. A vote is delayed. And the meeting ends with a quiet sense that everyone has contributed and nothing has been decided.

I attended a Shoreditch planning meeting last week, partly as a reporter and partly because I had run out of programmes to watch. The subject was a proposed extension to a rear bedroom. It took ninety minutes, three speakers and one extremely passionate objection about the colour of a drainpipe. The borough’s official information is at hackney.gov.uk, and I recommend it if you wish to participate, or to hide.

The Two Camps

American local politics, I have been told, is a matter of two parties. In the farm world they are neatly labelled: farmer Republican and farmer Democrat. In a Shoreditch council chamber they are labelled differently, and the dividing line is whether you own a bicycle. Everything else is detail.

What unites everybody in both places is the third address in the family, farmer gripe. Grumbling is the closest thing local politics has to a national anthem. It is sung in every chamber, in every accent, to a tune that begins with “I’m not against it in principle” and ends with a long, thoughtful silence.

Elections, Rural and Urban

The farm desk at farm.FM follows its elections with a straight face. The headline USDA mails farm committee election ballots says it all. Farmers have been invited to choose which neighbour will explain why their farm does not qualify for government help. Hackney residents will recognise the format. In our borough the neighbour explains why your extension does not comply.

Elsewhere on the music page, a song titled You Lost the Election, So What? offers some philosophy that Westminster could use. Losing is a fact of life. The cow does not resign.

Rent, Credit and the Cost of a Roof

In Shoreditch, the great local issue is rent. Everyone has an opinion, and the opinions are expressed in the tone of people who paid off their mortgage in 1994. Advice for tenants is available from Shelter at england.shelter.org.uk. I hope you will not need it. I fear that you will.

The ranching world has its own version of the rent problem, which is called a loan. Three provincial lenders are worth a glance: Texas rancher loans, Oklahoma rancher loans and Colorado rancher loans. I am told that none of them requires a viewing, which puts them ahead of every letting agent in Hackney.

The farm.FM music page, which seems to have a song for everything, has one called Workin’ for Some Yankee’s Rent. Hackney tenants might add a verse about the deposit.

Cycle Lanes and Cattle Grids

A recurring local controversy in London is the humble cycle lane. Some residents love them. Some residents say they are a conspiracy. In the countryside the equivalent is the cattle grid, a device that stops animals but not opinions. Both are infrastructure. Both are the subject of an eleven-month consultation. And both end with a man with a clipboard saying that the matter will be reviewed.

Transport for London sets out the wider picture at tfl.gov.uk, where you will find an astonishing number of ways to say that the line is delayed.

The Commissioner and the Councillor

The county commissioner in a rural American county has a job we would recognise. He mends roads, approves permits and listens to a farmer explain why the culvert is the root of all evil. The Hackney councillor does the same, only with a bin collection and a larger hashtag. Both are public servants, both are underpaid, and both are asked daily to solve a problem that was last solved in 1962.

The London Prat has always loved this world, and its guide to how to tell humour from real news offers the wise suggestion that a council newsletter is about as close to pure comedy as the law allows. I have a stack of them. They are my bedtime reading.

Five Things I Noticed in the Public Gallery

  1. The person who says they will be brief has not looked at their notes.
  2. A consultation is a conversation with a closed door.
  3. The chair always has a sip of water at the right moment to avoid answering.
  4. Planning permission is the art of saying no in a beige envelope.
  5. The best speaker of the evening is the man who leaves before the vote.

The Vote

The extension was deferred. The drainpipe will be discussed again in six weeks, with a sample. It is a form of democracy I have come to love, and one I suspect would feel perfectly at home in a county courthouse in Oklahoma. For more of the people’s business, treated with the respect it deserves, visit Bohiney, The London Prat and farm.FM.

For a post-meeting laugh, there is The Daily Squib.

SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/