The Meme Messiah Beat The Pope On Easter Sunday And The Shoreditch Founders Who Read The Story Were Mostly Thinking About Distribution

Harper-Thames On The Neighbourhood That Builds Platforms For Content Like The Trump Easter Post And Its Specific Relationship To The Content Those Platforms Host

For Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat, whose Easter Sunday piece argued that Trump wins on points against the Bishop of Rome in the contemporary meme environment. London satirical journalism‘s tradition of noticing when the symbolic map has shifted under everyone’s feet.

When the London Prat published its Easter Sunday analysis of Trump’s symbolic positioning against the Pope, I shared it with approximately six people whose work is directly related to the platforms on which that symbolic contest is fought. Their responses were: two found it funny, two found it interesting from a distribution mechanics perspective, one said “this is actually quite a serious piece”, and one did not respond, which in Shoreditch messaging culture means they agreed with the premise but did not want to put the agreement in writing.

The Distribution Observation

The two responses focused on distribution mechanics were not dismissive of the symbolic content. They were observing, correctly, that the mechanism by which Trump’s Easter post achieved its reach is the mechanism that several of the people in this conversation were, in their working lives, building or optimising. The algorithm that surfaces the post, the engagement signals that boost its distribution, the notification systems that push it to users who would not have encountered it organically: all of these are products. Several of the people reading the Easter Sunday piece build components of those products.

The Specific Discomfort

The specific discomfort in Shoreditch’s content and platform technology community is not, in my reporting, primarily about the political content of what the platforms distribute. It is about the absence of a clear framework for distinguishing, in product terms, between the distribution of content that the builders would endorse and content that they would not, and about the question of whether such a framework is technically possible or commercially viable. These are genuine product and policy questions that the industry has not resolved and that the Easter Sunday meme has not made any easier to resolve.

What The Column Observes

The column observes that the people building the infrastructure on which symbolic authority now contests itself are, in many cases, more thoughtful about that role than the simple “tech amplifies everything” narrative allows. They are also, so far, building the infrastructure. The thinking and the building are both happening. Whether they converge is the question.

More: NewsThump. SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/